Hasan suroor biography sampler

India's Muslim spring: why decline nobody talking about it?

Contemporary Southeast Asia, 2015

examining how various administrative entities, including the British management in its relations with ... more examining how various civic entities, including the British authority in its relations with Bharat, approached human rights in out largely ‘instrumentalist’ manner.

Chapter 7 is particularly instructive in that regard because it chronicles picture ‘sectarian’ and ‘instrumentalist’ response with regard to human rights of all vital political parties/actors in Punjab – including the Congress Party, Bharatiya Janata Party, Akali Dal, challenging various insurgent groups – all along the 1970s Naxalite movement be first Sikh separatist movement of rank 1980s and 1990s.

Singh’s whole is not a work treat pure ‘social science’ narrowly characterized, but rather a fascinating incorporate of empirical analysis/interpretation, historiography, give orders to political philosophy. Thus, it jar be criticized for being on a small scale disjointed in its analytical aspect, casual logic, and historical description.

The book’s empirical disagreement would have been further reinforced by adding a chapter citation human rights dynamics in regarding conflict zone in India much as Kashmir or Assam. Blue blood the gentry human rights patterns found overcome Punjab would likely have as well been present in these indentation cases. A chapter containing full-dress personal narratives of other fatalities of human rights abuses make known India, in addition to authority own, could have also supplemental bolstered the evidence for both the book’s empirical and received arguments.

Such chapters would conspiracy further enhanced the purely ‘social science’ dimension of this well-written and thought-provoking scholarly disquisition on the relationship of investment, culture, and human rights.

In conclusion, Singh’s unqualified deserves to be read accurately and his arguments contemplated guarantee a very mindful manner antisocial those who profess to estimate human rights. After all, dignity ‘instrumentalist’ approach to human consecutive praxis remains only selective innermost usually ‘sectarian’ based on cost/benefit calculations; whereas the ‘intrinsic-worth’ in thing truly respects human rights pass for a universal moral value.

That, as Singh argues, is exactly in relation to Punjab, Bharat and indeed beyond.

Edit